By Jennifer G. Hickey
09/16/97 10:21:04 PDT
The focus has been on Ron Carey and the Teamsters
election. However, this story of union influence, corruption and
money began not in 1996 but far earlier and with the complicity
of the Clinton administration.
In February 1996, AFL-CIO President John
Sweeney told a meeting of union executives in Bal Harbor, Fla.,
"We're going to mount a political-action effort of unprecedented
scale, with every union doing its share by contributing ideas,
money, staff, media and materials." From January 1995 to
June 1996, according to records of the Federal Election Commission,
or FEC, union political-action committees received $74 million
and contributed $26 million to congressional candidates, with
90 percent distributed to Democrats. Just Sweeney's AFL-CIO spent
$35 million on its own TV blitz and contributed a total of $1,180,014
to Democrats in the 1995-96 cycle, which contrasts pitifully with
the $14,000 donated to Republicans, according to the Center for
Responsive Politics, or CRP. That's 98 percent to 1 percent.
What did all of that money buy? While the
Republicans maintained control of both houses of Congress, 10
GOP incumbents were defeated and Bill Clinton was reelected --
garnering 25 percent of his votes from union families, according
to exit polls. Kenneth R. Weinstein of the conservative Heritage
Foundation in Washington says that big labor has been powerful
in recent campaigns because the unions are "a dedicated cadre
of liberal activists whose most important mission has been to
effect a social transformation of the political landscape."
The unions have, in fact, stinted on strike
funds and other member benefits to make their leaders politically
powerful by dipping into members' pockets. Under the Supreme Court's
1988 decision in Beck vs. Communications Workers of America, union
members are entitled to a refund of any portion of their compulsory
union dues used for political activities. That sum frequently
is estimated at $50 million -- with estimates of in-kind contributions
ranging from $300 million to $1 billion. In October 1992, President
Bush issued an executive order requiring federal contractors to
notify their union workers of their refund rights. Shortly after
he assumed office, Clinton revoked this order and has enjoyed
the benefit. The recent nullification of the 1996 Teamsters election
of Ron Carey -- notorious for alleged bankrolling of Democratic
Party causes with union funds -- and the hearings into the Democrats'
campaign-finance abuses, may have focused further attention on
the union attempts to change the political landscape in 1996,
but that is not when the story began.
Heritage's Weinstein says that in recent
years the unions have been able to influence national policy inordinately
because of their connections both to the DNC and the Clinton White
House. One such connection was Harold Ickes. While working for
the New York law firm of Meyer, Suozzi, English & Klein, Ickes
represented Local 100 of the Hotel and Restaurant Employees International
Union from 1983 until 1991 when he left to work for Clinton. Ickes
says he saw "no evidence of illegal activity whatsoever"
despite the facts that Local 100 Vice President John DeRoss was
convicted of corruption and Clinton's own Commission on Organized
Crime listed Ickes' client local as a tool of the Gambino crime
family.
In 1996, Ickes served as the main White House
fund-raiser for Clinton and the Democrats, as illustrated by his
release of reams of documents detailing his event-by-event and
month-by month knowledge of the DNC/Clinton-Gore fund-raising
machine and how much it was raising. Ickes also shared responsibility
for orchestrating the joint fund-raising efforts of the White
House, the DNC and related events such as the coffee klatches.
And one of the most important roles assigned by Clinton to Ickes
was to act as the administration's contact for Arthur Coia, president
of the Laborers International Union of North America, or LIUNA,
according to Coia. Indeed, the Coia union lent the first Clinton
Inaugural Committee $100,000. Since 1993, the Laborers' Political
League, LIUNA's PAC, has donated nearly $2 million to Democrat
congressional candidates.
In turn, LIUNA received more than $15 million
in federal grants between 1993 and 1996. In fiscal year 1996 it
garnered $11,094,000 in further grants. In addition, LIUNA was
provided with a $3.5 million contract from the Department of Housing
and Urban Development just three months after it admitted in federal
court to connections to organized crime.
According to the Heritage Foundation, LIUNA
officials have racked up more than 80 convictions for racketeering,
bribery, extortion and attempted murder. On Nov. 4, 1994, Coia
was served with a 212-page draft racketeering complaint from the
Justice Department's Organized Crime and Racketeering Section
-- a complaint that did not charge him with a crime but tasked
him with cleaning up LIUNA. On that same day, Clinton sent Coia
a handwritten thank-you note for a handmade golf club Coia had
given him. Furthermore, despite the fact that the head of Justice's
organized crime unit, Paul Coffey, had alerted the White House
to the impending draft complaint, Coia attended six events with
Clinton in the intervening period, including a dinner and a breakfast
at the White House. And, feeling the pain of the 1994 election
losses, Clinton tapped the shady Coia to cochair a 1995 New England
dinner, which aimed to raise $500,000, and a May 1996 fund raiser,
which collected $12 million.
Coia continued to exchange letters with Clinton
and, on Jan. 18, 1995, it was DNC Finance Chairman Alan Solomont
who co chaired that New England dinner with Coia. Less than three
weeks later, on Feb. 6, 1995, Hillary Rodham Clinton attended
a LIUNA conference and delivered a speech -- and Coia asserts
that he spoke to her about the Justice investigation. Two weeks
later, Justice informed Coia that if he promised to be good and
reform his union he could remain as president. LIUNA tells Insight
that Justice, FBI and congressional figures have praised its compliance.
"In general, you're not going to offend
a major source of support," F.C. "Duke" Zeller,
who served as Teamsters communications director for 14 years,
tells Insight. And Coia remained an important Clinton fund-raising
fixture in 1996, earning a spot on Ickes' list of top 10 contributors.
Critics are saying that, having gotten by with a not-very sophisticated
selling of favors to union-boss Coia, the Clinton administration
began doing the same favor for Carey by protecting him too.
According to Zeller in his book The Devil's
Pact: Inside the World of the Teamsters Union, as much as $56
million was diverted illegally from the Teamsters to the 1992
Clinton Gore campaign. This alleged diversion of funds left the
Teamsters as much as $52 million in debt in 1992. Zeller tells
Insight that, in 1992, there were "certainly some contributions
in a very strange manner," but having left the Teamsters
in 1992 he would not speak about the 1996 campaign. In detailing
the earlier campaign, however, Zeller points to a meeting between
Clinton and Ron Carey which occurred at Madison Square Garden
during the 1992 Democratic Convention. "This is when I believe
the channeling [of funds] began, if not sooner," Zeller tells
Insight.
During Carey's own 1996 run for reelection,
Jere Nash served as his campaign manager by day; nights and mornings,
Nash served as a Clinton campaign consultant. According to Barbara
Zack Quindel, the elections officer appointed by a federal court
to review the Teamsters election, Nash informed Carey's secretary
Monie Simpkins that "the [International Brotherhood of Teamsters]
was going to make contributions to certain political organizations
and in return, certain individuals would contribute to the Carey
campaign through [Teamsters for a Corrupt-Free Union]." Simpkins
told the investigating court officer that on at least one occasion
she informed Carey that a check he was approving "was one
that Mr. Nash had called about."
News reports say that in the summer of 1996,
Martin Davis, a Carey campaign consultant, met with Cary campaign
consultant Michael Ansara (who is cooperating with federal investigators)
and DNC finance official Richard Sullivan to discuss how to launder
money from the Teamsters' PAC to Democratic campaigns in exchange
for the DNC's requests that large Democratic donors contribute
to Carey's campaign. According to the CRP, Democrat Senate candidates
received $254,750 from the Teamsters, as opposed to the $10,700
given Republicans. In the House of Representatives the contrast
was $2,243,080 to Democratic coffers, and $90,110 to Republicans.
On Aug. 21, after holding back her report
during the Teamsters strike against UPS, Quindel released the
report invalidating Carey's election and requiring a new balloting.
She promptly became a focus of attention and anger from supporters
of Carey's opponent, James Hoffa Jr., following the announcement,
and she says she will resign. Quindel has admitted her membership
in Citizen Action, which suddenly received $475,000 from the Teamsters,
even though the union had awarded it an average of only $15,650
in the preceding four years. The money that went to Citizen Action
was funneled through Democratic offers to several individuals,
including Carey campaign consultant Ansara and his wife Barbara
Arnold, who then made the donation to Carey's campaign. Furthermore,
according to FEC records, Arnold contributed $1,500 to Minnesota
Democratic Sen. Paul Wellstone and a further $2,000 to the DNC
during the 1995-96 election cycle. Arnold's husband contributed
$1,000 to the DNC and $1,500 to the Massachusetts Democratic Party.
Whether that money came from the Teamsters is not known.
Zeller tells Insight he does not know if
there was a Clinton effort to withhold Quindel's decision until
after the UPS strike was concluded, though "she may have
been an agent of the Justice Department. I have no idea what their
timing was." Quindel did not return Insight's call. But an
investigator tells this magazine that there is much consternation
and anger among FBI officials about the decision to delay release
of the court-appointed election officer's report and the special
treatment labor unions have been receiving from the Clinton Justice
Department.