By TRACY CONNOR
June 30, 1998
Some 40,000 screaming construction workers
staged a raucous demonstration that exploded in violence and paralyzed
Midtown Manhattan yesterday - catching city officials flat-footed.
"The union leaders changed the location
and way underestimated the numbers," Mayor Giuliani fumed.
"They told us at maximum they expected
10,000. We were prepared for 15,000. Our estimate is that ...
40,000 showed up ... What they did was totally unacceptable."
Eighteen cops were injured, none seriously,
in a series of clashes with angry protesters, who hurled bottles
and rushed barricades. Three demonstrators, including a union member
who was trampled by a police horse, also were hurt in the melee.
Some were hit with pepper spray by police.
Thirty-two demonstrators were arrested.
The Building Trades Council scheduled the
demonstration to protest the Metropolitan Transportation Authority's
awarding of a $33 million contract to Roy Kay Inc., which uses
non union workers. Charges included disorderly conduct, assaulting
police officers, and riot - plus one charge of hitting a police
horse, officials said. A Daily News photographer was arrested for
allegedly violating police orders, but the charges were later
dismissed "in the interest of media relations," an NYPD
spokeswoman said.
The city vowed to prosecute the arrested
unionists and said it will subpoena TV camera footage to identify
other rioters. It also plans to sue the organizers of the
march for damages and seek an injunction to limit future protests,
said Giuliani, who canceled a trip upstate after rowdy builders
rampaged across major thoroughfares during a five-hour demonstration.
The NYPD issued a permit for 10,000 workers
and deployed 550 cops to keep order at the MTA headquarters on
Madison Avenue and 45th Street. The crowd quickly swelled far beyond the
original estimate as union job sites across the city shut down,
freeing workers to join the protest.
The chanting, flag-waving demonstrators ignored
police instructions to disperse and some began throwing bottles
and umbrellas as cops tried to contain the crowd, police said
"It was supposed to be peaceful, but
it turned into "Let's see how many blocks we can close,'"
one beleaguered cop said. The group took over Sixth Avenue and other
major streets on a crosstown trek to the MTA job site on Ninth
Avenue, bringing traffic to a standstill.
The NYPD called in 450 reinforcements - including
mounted cops and helicopters, officials said. "The police acted very, very quickly
and swiftly to get the requisite number of police officers there,
given the fact they were surprised by this," Giuliani said.
"The whole group never got out of control.
Although the Police Department was playing catch-up, they always
kept it within at least some degree of bounds."
Police Commissioner Howard Safir downplayed
the violence and said the NYPD is always prepared for protests
of any size. "There were some scattered incidents
and some minor violence," he said. "Generally, it was
a pretty well-behaved crowd."
As the protesters marched from MTA headquarters
to Ninth Avenue and 53rd Street and back, there were several ugly,
chaotic confrontations with police. The most serious erupted when cops struggled
to keep the mob away from the non-union work site and used pepper
spray to keep the crowd at bay. Groups of workers - some of whom made pit
stops in local bars and carried beer bottles through the streets
- also attacked an MTA truck and two vehicles they suspected were
doing non-union work.
Safir said there were no early indications
of trouble. "The demonstrators were acting in an
orderly manner. Then suddenly there appeared to be a change in
their demeanor. I don't know what triggered it, if anything,"
he said.
Defending their own actions, union officials
condemned the violence and vandalism. "If it happened, it was wrong. We don't
condone it," Paul Fernandes, assistant to the president of
the Building Trades Council, said of the violence. "But I would point out 99.9 percent
of the people behaved themselves."
Fernandes said the council told the NYPD
it expected "at least" 10,000 protesters and cautioned
officials they were shutting down all construction projects in
the city, he said. "We didn't intentionally underestimate
the size of the crowd," Fernandes said. "It's very hard
to get into the mind of our membership."
Protesters said they needed strength in numbers
to show they won't tolerate non-union contracts. "The city will crumble if we allow non-union
workers at sites. They're unqualified. Their work is shoddy,"
said Kevin Regan, 41, a plumber. "The city has been infested
by these non-union workers, and Kay is the biggest roach."
Stanley Kopilow, a lawyer for the charged
protesters, called the arrests "an overreaction." "It's
really unfortunate that people in 1998 have to protest on the
streets to be able to work with dignity. This is not about crime
- it's about working with dignity." Some protesters claimed the NYPD inflamed
tensions by sending cops in riot gear to keep the peace. "They
tried to intimidate us, but we're not going to be intimidated,"
said steelworker John Rodriguez, 32. "I think they panicked."
But cops said they were trying to keep a
bad situation from getting worse. "They sprayed us with pepper
spray. They were throwing bottles. We were just doing our job.
Stop blaming us," one officer said.
Copyright
(c) 1998, N.Y.P. Holdings, Inc.